Thursday, December 04, 2008
Deployment Forum HomeDeployment Forum ArticlesDeployment Forum Download LibraryDeployment Forum Member BlogsDeployment Forum Community Forums
Member Login
StandardLiveID


Register
Forgot Password ?



Guests can view and read messages in the community forums, but you must register and log in to Deployment Forum before you can post messages. Click Register at the top of this page. Before posting messages, please read the forum guidelines at the bottom of this page.

Subject: Is the Workbench Obsolete in SCCM ?
Prev Next
You are not authorized to post a reply.

AuthorMessages
Or TsemahUser is Offline

Posts:53

Send Message
01/28/2008 2:53 AM  

Hi,

Just wanted to clerify for myself

Is the Deployment Workbench completely obsolete from using SCCM 2007 With MDT after integration ?

If so, there still seems to be some jobs that the SCCM console can't do like:

1. Edit the CS.ini \ Bootstrap.ini \ Unattend.xml (Although available through available through the WAIK Tools)

2. Add drivers not from UNC (What's the deal with that, anyway)

3. Add patches and LP

4. Edit the DB

Can someone clerify on what is given control to the SCCM and what remains in the DW ?

A nice Geek guide would be great also

BTW, SCCM is great, i just think it could be better conjoined with the DW, What do you think ?

Or.

Mark AllcockUser is Offline

Posts:13

Send Message
02/29/2008 6:46 AM  

Yes, the Deployment Workbench as we know it is completely redundant for deployments created using SCCM 2007.

How you deal with the points you raised, I will answer:

1. As follows:

Customsettings.ini - you will have to edit this from within the "Settings" package source using notepad. Once your changes are made you will then need to update the Distribution Point.

Bootstrap.ini - this is not a part of SCCM (ConfigMgr) deployments so you will not need to configure it.

Unattend.xml - continue to use the System Installation Manager from the WAIK as usual.

2. Drivers - you should be creating a "Drivers Package" when you import the Task Sequence template from Microsoft Deployment Toolkit.

3. Patches - again, you should make use of the "Software Updates" functionality in SCCM for this.

4. DB Management - this is a grey area. If you rely on a separate database then you will have to manage this through SQL Management Studio, however, we only used to use a separate database to define things like the computer name and the packages that are installed according to the selected role. Our implementation has managed to completely do away with the need for a separate database by utilising most of the inbuilt functions of SCCM - for instance, Roles that define packages are now defined by collection membership. Our scripts enumerate every "Role Collection" that the computer object is a member of and installs the packages that are advertised to that collection. It's not as simple as that however we've made it work with some pretty extensive scripting.

Overall, I do not see the need for the Deployment Workbench when you can do everything and more from ConfigMgr (SCCM). It was a little difficult to get used to at first but you eventually get the hang of it.

Hope this goes some way to answering your questions.

Or TsemahUser is Offline

Posts:53

Send Message
03/03/2008 2:30 AM  

Thanks for the detailed reploy

However, it seems that this new way is more complex

For instance, how can i restore computer names to Bare Metal  machines (Pre-Stage) them without using the MDT's DB ?

Or

 

KaiserUser is Offline

Posts:9

Send Message
05/27/2008 4:24 AM  

Hi I'm new to SCCM…

In SCCM without MDT integrated, how do you set regional settings (clients deployed from different locations around the world) and keyboard the easiest way ?

Mike DzikowskiUser is Offline
Deployment Forum MVP

Posts:120

Send Message
08/22/2008 3:26 PM  

To the question in your subject line, yes. When integrating ConfigMgr and MDT - the workbench is no longer utilized.

Mike Dzikowski 

 


Mike Dzikowski, MCP
You are not authorized to post a reply.
Forums > Related Technologies > System Center Configuration Manager 2007 > Is the Workbench Obsolete in SCCM ?



ActiveForums 3.7
Forum Policies
Minimize

These forums are a user-supported community for IT professionals to exchange deployment tips, solutions, and techniques. For the benefit of all Deployment Forum members, please observe the following guidelines when posting to these forums:

  • We reserve the right to remove any message. Our moderators will remove all messages that are not respectful or productive. Profanity, racism, prejudice, and flaming are not tolerated.
  • Do not advertise products or services. Our moderators will remove all advertisements or service announcements. Product and service recommendations from active Deployment Forum members are encouraged, however.
  • Make sure your question isn't already answered. Before posting questions, search the forums. After ensuring that your questions are unique, post them to the most appropriate forum. This will help reduce noise in the forums.
  • Help make the most of each thread. Do not post unrelated messages to a thread. Also, if you've resolved a question outside of these forums, please share the solution with other members by posting it back to the thread.
  • Do not share confidential information. Confidential information includes product keys and addresses. Our moderators will edit any message containing confidential information, so double-check messages and their attachments before posting them.
  • Post messages using only the English language. For the benefit of all Deployment Forum members, please post your messages using the English language.

We hope that you enjoy using this community. Please submit your comments and feedback on the Comments and Feedback page or post them to the Comments, Feedback forum.



Privacy Statement  |  Terms Of Use
© 2007 Jerry Honeycutt